I woke up this morning to find my facebook page inundated with messages about Congress ramming inappropriate things down our collective throats, killing babies, nuking the Constitution and apparently losing the Cold war 20 years after it ended and falling to the red devils. Yes, last night the House passed the Health care bill (or as Facebook tells me, America, freedom and democracy died last night.)
I'll admit, I was fairly excited. I hadn't been vigilantly following the health care bill for the past month or so; after months of exhaustive analysis it just got too frustrating to continually watch things swing around without ever moving forward. Frankly I doubted anything was ever going to actually happen. So as I munched on my morning toast, I happily moused over to CNN to see what had actually gotten passed.
What socialist delight would await me? A public option perhaps? Tough reforms for the insurance industry? Puppies for everyone? With all the outrage, it had to be something good.
Uhm, seriously? This is the lamest, mildest bill I've ever seen. The government is taking over health care the same way the government takes over food by requiring it to be safe and restricting our freedom to buy spoiled, salmonella ridden beef. The government isn't running anything. This is still an entirely private system, just with some very wussy regulation tossed in. This is barely health care reform, it's just incremental insurance regulation.
People. This isn't socialism. This is like the wild west finally getting a sheriff, only the sheriff is giving the outlaws a few years to shape up and some subsidies to help the bitter taste of law go down a little easier.
Oh, and that 73% of people hate the bill thing? Most lefties are probably in that number. This isn't what we want. I'm not nuts about the bill. I wanted a single payer system. Or at the very least a decent public option, you know, as a compromise. (You can use your beloved private companies, and I can get decent insurance, with low overhead, less stupid denials and still afford to eat!)
I'm ok with this bill. I'm ok with making it illegal to deny coverage to domestic violence victims and others with preexisting conditions. I'm ok with trying to make healthcare more affordable and accessible through insurance polls, subsidies (sort of) and regulations.
I'm less ok with some other parts. I understand the reasoning behind fining individuals, but it bothers me that we're forcing people to purchase a flawed product without giving them a real alternative. I'm a little worried about unintended consequences too.
But overall this isn't really what I was looking for. It doesn't get to the heart of the problem, it doesn't fix or rework our already hodgepodge system, it just slaps on some more duct tape over the worst failings and adds a few new leaks.
Really, if even after all the compromises and watering down, we're still going to get screamed at for being evil, moronic, socialists and get no bipartisan support or even honest discussion (from members of Congress, not necessarily all individuals. For MoC, just saying lets start from scratch and do everything our way while calling names doesn't count), why couldn't we have just done a good, solid bill, the kind Democrats (you know, the ones who were elected by a huge majority to the House, Senate and Presidency by America in 2008?) actually campaigned on and wanted?
I'm generally avoiding this debate because, well, I'm Canadian and therefore don't intrinsically understand American health care or health care reform very comprehensively.
ReplyDeleteHowever, I find it entertaining and mildly offensive that some Americans think that a national health care system such as Canada's or Great Britain's would entail critically wounded people screaming in overcrowded, dirty, underfunded hospitals. Or that a system where everyone is included without exception is a bad thing. Someone commented "don't you know? now your tax dollars will go to pay for someone else's insurance!" To which I say..seriously? Your tax dollars go towards someone else's roads and schools too. I can't imagine being sick and not being able to afford to see a doctor. I really hope real change happens for American health care for that sake!
(so much for not getting involved. I'm stepping off my soap box now!)
Genavee, i cannot agree with you at all...this bill is ONLY the beginning of the tear down of America..there is more to come...and then more and more to take away our rights and freedoms...just the way this bill was crafted alone should be enough to make anyone mad...unless they didn't like America to begin with..heck Obama is LOVED in Germany! Why??? Because it's socialists make up...30 to 80 % unemployment depending on where in Germany you live..France 30%+ socialism has never ever won only if a dictator tries to enforce control over a country
ReplyDeleteIf that happens here...those in DC better watch out!
Seriously though. I mean, if the Congresspeople are going to be threatened with actual violence (see, among other things, the above comment), called niggers and faggots, and beaten down by mass hysteria... they may as well have gone for the gusto.
ReplyDeleteWhy waste all that energy getting a lame-a bill that they then have to pretend is the savior of the American healthcare system & the far-right has to pretend is the end of the world... when we all know it is nothing of either sort.
HAHA, I loved the thing about the sheriffs.
ReplyDeleteAlso, Facebook last night/this morning was totally a war zone. Most of my FB friends lean pretty liberal, but apparently this whole issue has brought out the far-right fringe in people who I never knew had it in them. (THEY'RE TAKING AWAY OUR FREEDOM! Um, by not letting us drop insurance coverage when someone's actually sick?)
I could rant probably forever about health care reform/people who oppose it/the idiot doctors and representatives and people with no apparent qualifications whatsoever who on air and rave about how we have 'the best healthcare system in the world' (um, actually? We're ranked THIRTY-SEVENTH, according to the WHO). But in the meantime, it's refreshing to read this post and know that not at least one person going into the law world is not totally insane.
... But maybe my common sense is being obscured by the fact that, apparently, by wanting everyone to have access to healthcare I'm a communist.
Oh, you socialist, you!
ReplyDeleteBut honestly, I agree with almost everything you said. The bill is mild and doesn't fix nearly enough of the problems, but it's a start.
I'm so sick of all this rhetoric being tossed around about who "likes" or "hates" America and the "taking back our country" crap.
My one concern about the pre-existing conditions situation: Insurance companies can't deny you coverage, but will they just jack up their premiums if you have, heaven forbid, a predisposition to seasonal allergies? Or a history of infertility? Or, oh my goodness, bad eyesight? Cause, if so, my husband and I are screwed. But, under the current health care state of affairs, we already are. So go figure.
You don't know me, but AMEN.
ReplyDeleteHell yes. I agree with everything that you said. I wish we were friends in real life.
ReplyDeleteI agree with the other comment if we are going to get called, n*ggers, socialist, faggots, communist, then we should go for broke.
The republicans didn't care what dems thought while they were in office, so why don't we have a public option.
I love all of the people saying dems are uneducated and need to take a class in econ. It's like hello, have a business degree and I would like them to take a look at what happened in 1937 when there was a mob like mentality as there is now and they pulled back on public funding after pulling the economy out of the gutter, and then the economy sunk into a deeper depression.
AHHH. I could go on, especially about my friend that had cancer and got in law school and now he can only get coverage through the state that barely covers anything and they make him pay $500 a month and he had to pick up the tab for 4 rounds of chemo.
Bless your heart.
ReplyDeleteI passed this post along to my friend who has an in-law who apparently wants all her Obama-voting facebook friends to DELETE THEMSELVES from her friend list. Gotta love that rational, conservative behavior ... like removing relatives from your facebook for their political opinions.
I could not agree more. One of my FB friends said he wanted the whole state of VA to secede, and another suggested that a move to TX where it would be easier to do just that. Yet another shouted that socialism had won and that it was a sad day for Americans. I thought for sure this meant that something fantastic had happened with the bill. And then, when I realized what had been passed, I said: "Oh. Really?" I think they should have gone balls out with this bill. I'm not sure why everyone is freaking out over something so tame.
ReplyDeleteGreat post.
here HERE! I am so peeved at people complaining. LET ME COMPLAIN BY SAYING SHUT UP :)
ReplyDeletesilly americans.
ReplyDelete